Dworkin's Dignity Under the Lens of the Magician of Königsberg

Rodriguez-Blanco, Veronica (2018) Dworkin's Dignity Under the Lens of the Magician of Königsberg In: Dignity in Dworkin’s Legal and Moral Philosophy. Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Text 11. Chapter 8 (Rodriguez-Blanco).pdf - Proof Restricted to Repository staff only Download (129kB)

Abstract

I will argue that Dworkin’s limiting condition of dignity, whose defining pillars are self-respect and authenticity, cannot establish the required boundaries to guarantee a place for morality in the ethical domain. As a result the ‘constructive model’does not offer a genuine integration between morality and ethics. On the contrary, morality is pushed aside and the remaining space is for ethical responsibilities alone. In Dworkinean language what is left is ‘living well’, i.e. striving to have a good life without limiting conditions. I show that under Dworkin’s constructive model, the ‘source’of the performance and activities in our striving to live well is not necessarilyour rational nature.

In§2 I discuss Dworkin’s idea of dignity and his constructive model with the aim of overcoming the separation between morality and ethics. In §3 I contrast Dworkin’s notion of dignity with the Kantian notion of dignity and show that my reading of the Kantian conception of dignity provides opportunity for the integration of ethics and morality. I also discuss a possible objection to my proposal.

Item Type:	Book Section
Divisions :	Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences > School of Law
Authors :	Name Email ORCID Rodriguez-Blanco, Veronica v.rodriguez-blanco@surrey.ac.uk
Date :	2018
Copyright Disclaimer :	© 2017 Oxford University Press
Depositing User :	Clive Harris
Date Deposited :	01 Sep 2017 10:17
Last Modified :	16 Jan 2019 18:56
URI:	http://epubs.surrey.ac.uk/id/eprint/842125

Actions (login required)

View Item

Downloads